Bitcoin has once again ignited discussions surrounding its legitimacy as an investment asset, particularly following critical remarks from a high-ranking executive at Vanguard Group. During Bloomberg’s “ETFs in Depth” conference in New York, John Ameriks, Vanguard’s Global Head of Quantitative Equity, expressed his skepticism about Bitcoin, labeling it as a speculative “digital toy.”
Ameriks pointed out that Bitcoin does not align with traditional investment criteria that his firm typically looks for, such as income generation, compounding growth, and positive cash flow. Drawing a rather vivid analogy, he likened Bitcoin to a trendy collectible plush toy, specifically a “digital Labubu,” further emphasizing his stance that without substantiated evidence of durable economic value, Bitcoin remains largely a speculative venture.
Interestingly, despite these reservations, Vanguard has opened its trading platform to allow clients to access spot Bitcoin exchange-traded funds (ETFs). This move came in the wake of the launch of U.S. spot Bitcoin ETFs earlier in 2024, which Ameriks noted had established necessary trading track records. However, he clarified that Vanguard does not intend to roll out its own crypto-focused ETFs, nor will the firm offer specific guidance on trading digital assets.
Ameriks did acknowledge that there are certain situations—such as periods of high inflation or political turmoil—where Bitcoin could potentially demonstrate value beyond speculation. Nevertheless, he argued that a solid investment thesis would require Bitcoin to consistently behave in a stable manner under such conditions, something its track record has yet to prove.
In terms of Bitcoin’s current market performance, after a significant sell-off, the cryptocurrency has shown signs of stabilization. Recently, Bitcoin had rebounded close to $85,000 but currently trades below key moving averages, which are crucial indicators of market position. Analysts are watching closely as BTC has developed higher lows, suggesting a reduction in downside momentum.
Immediate support levels for Bitcoin are identified between $88,500 and $89,000, with major support resting at $85,000. On the upside, the first resistance level is around $92,500, with a more substantial supply zone found between $96,000 and $98,000. A breakthrough above $96,000 could indicate a shift in market momentum, whereas a drop below $88,500 could trigger a quick retest of the $85,000 support level.
While the debate around the cryptocurrency continues, Vanguard remains optimistic about blockchain technology’s potential to enhance market structures—a sentiment that suggests a recognition of the underlying technology, even as skepticism persists regarding Bitcoin as a standalone investment.
