Concerns are rising over the shifting landscape of return policies among major retailers, as many now impose fees on customers looking to return unwanted gifts following the holiday season. This trend marks a significant change in the traditionally hassle-free process of returning merchandise, prompting consumers to carefully consider their options before mailing items back.
Retail giants are introducing various charges for mail-in returns. Macy’s has announced a fee of $9.99, while both TJ Maxx and Marshalls have set their return costs at $11.99. Other retailers like J. Crew, Abercrombie & Fitch, H&M, and Zara have also joined the fray, enforcing charges ranging from $3.99 to $7.50 for mail-in returns. Notably, Best Buy has escalated costs for returning certain electronics, with fees reaching up to $45.
Amazon, a key player in e-commerce, has also revised its return policies. Customers may now face charges unless they opt for its box-free, in-person drop-off method. The National Retail Federation reveals that American consumers are anticipated to return approximately $850 billion worth of merchandise this year, with nearly 20% of online purchases expected to be returned.
David Sobie, co-founder of Happy Returns, a company leveraging artificial intelligence to streamline the return process, suggests that recent tariff policies from the White House may be influencing these changes. Sobie stated in an interview that “merchants are under tremendous cost pressure” and are gradually shifting some of these costs back to consumers.
To avoid incurring unexpected fees, Sobie recommends that shoppers familiarize themselves with the return policies of retailers before making a purchase. As this trend continues, consumers may find themselves rethinking their return strategies in light of these new financial implications.

